I recently had a conversation with a friend here at SFTS that I was expecting for a while. My friend is an evangelical – I use a lower-case “e” because he isn’t necessarily associated with everything the big-E term entails. That’s his background, though, and to a degree where his expectations about what it means to be Christian were formed.

We had a really great conversation which was partly composed of me trying to explain the peculiarness of Presbyterianism. His basic question was “what are the students doing here? Why are they in Seminary?” See, we don’t always come off as at all passionate about what we do. Our worship services can get very dirge-like at times. Having spoken to my friend a bit about his background, I could sort of see this on the horizon.

This problem keeps coming up, over and over again, and it looks like it will be definitive for the future of the Church as a whole. Let us deal with stereotypes for a moment, just to put the problem in stark terms:

Evangelical: politically conservative, Biblically literalist and suspicious of “higher” criticism, passionate, conversion-experience focused, personal piety, missionary zeal, unconcerned with or suspicious of social gospel and social justice movements

Liberal: politically moderate to liberal, Biblically illiterate with lip-service to “higher” criticism, reserved, verbose, conversion seen as socialization, focus on social issues and social justice, reluctant to evangelize or deal with the Gospel outside of Jesus’ ethics

In short – both represent a sort of half-Christianity, and neither one frankly cuts it. Not for me anyway, and not for a lot of people I talk to about things like this. In my vivid but clumsy metaphor, one side focuses on feeding the furnace of the train without consideration for where it is going, and the other side focuses on fiddling with little dials and levers and never looks back to see if the boiler is hot.

Neither one looks very much like Jesus, and that’s a problem. John Shelby Spong doesn’t look anything like Jesus, and Jerry Falwell doesn’t look anything like him either. So what do we do? That’s on huge question that I’m here self-consciously trying to answer, if possible. In Ohio I’m a rabid radical liberal, and in California I’m a lackluster conservative, and in neither case do I really care about the labels. Is it that someone else is defining our question for us? Is it that we don’t have the courage or the voice to define it ourselves? What’s the answer when everyone says they’re doing what Jesus would do and almost none of them seem to be anywhere near correct?

One thought on “Half-Christians

  1. There’s at least a half dozen really good questions here. My spin on it, the problem isn’t choosing to be “liberal” or “evangelical”. Your train metaphor actually works here. The problem is that the people shovelling coal don’t get along with the people fiddling with knobs. We can only be half Christians (or less) by ourselves. The real problem is liberals’ disdain for evangelicals and vice versa. We need each other. We need to temper each other and hold each other accountable. The problem is that our dialogues always breakdown into quarrels and bickering matches. I’m in the same spot as you. In PA I’m a flaming liberal. Here, I might as well be Bible thumping. We forget the whole body of Christ metaphor so easily. As eyes, we tell ears all the time that we don’t need them and then we’re left with one, big, scary looking eye. Liberals and conservatives need each other. The other problem that you rightly pointed out is that we have let people outside of the conversation define us. When the media says “Christian” or “evangelical” they mean conservative, republican, anti-abortion, anti-gay rights, etc…I’m Christian and I’m none of those things. When as a Christian I am portrayed that way I get angry. That anger needs to somehow translate into a refusal to let anyone other than myself and anything other than my actions define me. The media does it to us. In turn we do it to each other.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s